Which song should song sing?

Honestly, neither. Both are Disney songs and will give a bad impression. They will have the song from the movie in their heads, and they'll compare you to that, which can be disastrous. Go on youtube and look up Much More from The Fantasticks. Practice the first minute and sing that. Its a good pick because its not a show known to the public (like Wicked, Rent, or any Disney show) so it shows that you aren't an ingenue. What are you auditioning for? If you must pick one your two songs though, do Looking through your eyes because it isn't as well known and the chance of the judges remembering it are low. Good luck!